AUCTION  / 

The Fireplace: NJ's Most Iconic Restaurant, The Auction!

Auction CurrencyUSD Auction Location147 Hamilton Avenue, Hasbrouck Heights, New Jersey, 07604, United States

Auction Details

Opening in 1956 by former FBI agent & WWII veteran Frank Reilly, The Fireplace Restaurant on Rt.17 North in Paramus, NJ, would eventually grow to become the highway’s most iconic building and eatery. It’s big red sign, brick facade, and many wood burning fireplaces welcomed everyone from proms and football celebrations to birthdays and weekly friend hangouts. This was the place to gather, and for many, The Fireplace was their 2nd home.

After 65 years of flipping burgers, serving pizzas, and hosting breakfast, The Fireplace Restaurant permanently closed their doors in July of 2021. Since then, the restaurant has mostly remained intact and as it was..…until now!

Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC is honored to be the sole liquidator and auctioneer representing the entire remaining contents of “New Jersey’s Most Iconic Restaurant”!

An online auction, via icollector.com, will launch early this week and feature everything from the original chandeliers and cast iron railings to food trays and vintage china. This auction promises to be the ultimate event for any past customer or employee looking to take a piece of history home with them. The most popular items up for auction will surely be the original menu board signs but there will be plenty for everyone.

The auction is scheduled to begin on Wednesday, June 21st with lots closing in the evening on Monday, June 26th. Items can be picked up directly from The Fireplace Restaurant in Paramus, NJ at 718 Rt.17 North on June 27th from 5pm to 7pm and June 28th from 5pm to 7pm. If any dining tables are left, they MAY be available for direct purchase during the 2 pick-up time slots as listed previously. All other items will ONLY be available via online bidding. No direct purchases will be allowed.

If anyone has any pick-up schedule conflicts or general questions, please text Ed Frischkorn (Operations Manager of Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC) at 917-410-7100.
- Please do not contact The Fireplace Restaurant concerning purchases.
- For all questions and inquiries, please text Ed Frischkorn at 201-639-4811.
- All measurements are in inches.
- Display fixtures not included.
- Buyer uses their own tools for removal.
- This facility has no power or running water. All power tools needed must be cordless.
- Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC & The Fireplace Corp. are not responsible for any injuries.
- These items are being sold as collectibles.
< Prev# Rows102050100Next >123. . .2829303132333435
 Choose Your Layout > Switch to Grid View Switch to List View
The Fireplace Restaurant - 3 Tier Rolling Custodial Cart626 - The Fireplace Restaurant - 3 Tier Rolling Custodial Cart
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Dusty. Needs A Good Cleaning But Still Usable.
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (10.00 + 1.50BP) = 11.50
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float627 - The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float628 - The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float629 - The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float630 - The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float631 - The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - HUGE Hand Painted Brick Wooden Plywood Panels From Their Parade Float
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (10.00 + 1.50BP) = 11.50
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Large Group Of Wooden Street Barricades632 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Large Group Of Wooden Street Barricades
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Many Available And Included In This Lot.
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Gifford's Ice Cream Sign633 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Gifford's Ice Cream Sign
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - Gifford's Ice Cream Sign
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (10.00 + 1.50BP) = 11.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - Interior Wooden Entrance Door W/ 3 Windows634 - Original The Fireplace Restaurant - Interior Wooden Entrance Door W/ 3 Windows
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - Interior Wooden Entrance Door W/ 3 Windows
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 100.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - Interior Wooden Entrance Door W/ 3 Windows635 - Original The Fireplace Restaurant - Interior Wooden Entrance Door W/ 3 Windows
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - Interior Wooden Entrance Door W/ 3 Windows
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 100.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier636 - Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (50.00 + 7.50BP) = 57.50
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Coat Hook637 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Coat Hook
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Coat Hook
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (40.00 + 6.00BP) = 46.00
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture638 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture639 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier640 - Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (50.00 + 7.50BP) = 57.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier641 - Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (70.00 + 10.50BP) = 80.50
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture642 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier643 - Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
Original The Fireplace Restaurant - 5 Globe Wagon Wheel Chandelier
Bidding Has Concluded
Sold for (50.00 + 7.50BP) = 57.50
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture644 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture645 - The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Remember When Antiques and Estate Sales, LLC
The Fireplace Restaurant - Wall Mounted Lantern Lighting Fixture
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 10.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark