141

Leon Trotsky

Currency:USD Category:Collectibles / Autographs Start Price:NA Estimated At:35,000.00 - 45,000.00 USD
Leon Trotsky

Bidding Over

The auction is over for this lot.
The auctioneer wasn't accepting online bids for this lot.

Contact the auctioneer for information on the auction results.

Search for other lots to bid on...
Auction Date:2019 Sep 12 @ 18:00 (UTC-5 : EST/CDT)
Location:15th Floor WeWork, Boston, Massachusetts, 02108, United States
ALS - Autograph Letter Signed
ANS - Autograph Note Signed
AQS - Autograph Quotation Signed
AMQS - Autograph Musical Quotation Signed
DS - Document Signed
FDC - First Day Cover
Inscribed - “Personalized”
ISP - Inscribed Signed Photograph
LS - Letter Signed
SP - Signed Photograph
TLS - Typed Letter Signed
Extraordinary archive of 18 TLSs in German and English by Leon Trotsky, totaling 19 pages, dated from 1932–1939. A series of highly political letters written during Trotsky’s exile to his confidant Albert Glotzer, who, together with James P. Cannon and Max Shachtman, had founded the Trotskyist movement in the USA. Beginning shortly after Glotzer’s extensive visit with Trotsky in Prinkipo, they mainly discuss the problems of concentrating the forces of the International Left Opposition against Stalin in Europe and America, the tactics in dealing with moderate parties and groups (the so-called "Centrists"), and the fragmentation tendencies among the American comrades; the final letter concerns the question of a Jewish state to be founded in Palestine. The great Russian revolutionary signs off as "L. Trotsky" twelve times, "L. Ty" once, "Leon Trotsky" three times, once with a pencil paraph, and once with an alias, "R. Ruskin." Thirteen of the letters also have handwritten closings or courtesies by Trotsky.

Excerpts from the English letters include:

July 12, 1933, offering advice on the state of the Communist League of America: "I want to write you again about the very dangerous situation in the League. The crisis is typical of the transition from one stage of development into another. But there have been examples in the history of human society when the crisis of transition became so acute, and absorbed so much strength, that society instead of marching forward, collapsed. The same result has been observed, much more frequently, in the history of political organizations. I am afraid that a similar fate threatens the League."

November 21, 1933, about a forthcoming Youth Conference: "The initiator is the O.S.P. This fact has its positive as well as its negative sides. O.S.P. is a left centrist party which will still give us not a little trouble. Its advantage lies in the fact that it is composed entirely of young workers."

June 3, 1937: "Everybody here admires your work, especially in view of my terrible English. You functioned not only as a stenographer but also as an English teacher and editor. Some corrections will be proposed by Wolfe and Ruth Ageloff, but they are not numerous. Without your work (and the help of Comrade Reva) we could never have such a record, and the hearings in Mexico would lose half their value. I thank you wholeheartedly."

September 11, 1937: "The creation of an independent party with about 2000 members is a very important step forward. The inner regime in the party is of the greatest importance. It must be a regime of a genuine democracy…Democracy presupposes not only formal political but pedagogical approach, to new members, and to every workers' audience. It is correct that the leadership should be patient in its approach to the membership as the party in its approach to the working masses. Insofar I agree with you. But there are methods to fight for party democracy, which are very dangerous to this aim. The present leadership—I mean all its members—is not an accidental one: it is a result of a selection of a long period of struggle…to try to change the leadership by some too-impatient, too sharp measures can become fatal and I can't conceal my impression that in your letter there are some disquieting systems."

September 27, 1937: "It is very possible that my impression concerning the danger of an inner struggle was false. But please don't forget that I am an observer from afar and I expressed my impression only in a positive letter to yourself. Your assertion: 'An inner struggle in the present period would be fatal to the new movement' gives me the necessary assurance. Everything must be done in order to eliminate the psychological remnants of the struggle of '36. For my part I am ready to do everything which could help that purpose."

February 2, 1939: "How are affairs in general in Chicago?…What is the situation in the trade unions? What is the situation in the youth? In April of 1937 you had a fine plan of coming to Mexico with Reva for your vacations. At that time you hoped to save enough money for the undertaking, but I am afraid that you did not succeed; and in spite of the Roosevelt prosperity cannot give us the pleasure of seeing you and Reva here."

February 14, 1939, offering important views on the "Jewish question" and prescient insight on the forthcoming world war: "Ruskin is interested in the Jewish question and I suppose he has some official function in connection with Palestine. He questioned me as to what I thought about Palestine and the possible interference of the USSR in favor of the creation of a Jewish state and so on. There are 400,000 Jews in Palestine, but Ruskin and his associates hope to place 500,000 more there. (How? When?) I answered him that they were preparing a fine trap for the Jews in Palestine. Before you settle 500,000 people, you will have an inner Palestine question with the 2,500,000 United States Jews. With the decline of American capitalism, anti-semitism will become more and more terrible in the United States—in any case, more important than in Germany. If the war comes, and it will come, a good many Jews will fall as the first victims of the war and will be practically exterminated. 'But,' he answered, 'it is necessary to do something.' Yes, but something effective. The French Revolution and then the October Revolution accomplished a bit more for the Jews than did Zionism and the other specific 'solutions' to a question that has no solution under the regime of declining capitalism. Only the international revolution can save the Jews."

September 18, 1939 (signed "R. Ruskin"): "You will have, I assume, the greater half of the party composed of new elements. They agree with you on the principles but lack concrete experience of applying these principles. Their organizational education is totally different from yours. That is why your objections and arguments can receive in their heads a totally different meaning. Let us take, for example, the question, whether it was or was not reasonable to enter the Socialist Party. For the 'natives' the question does not exist at all. Your entry into the S.P. helped them to find the genuine, revolutionary road, and they will be at a loss even to understand the clash of opinions among their new leaders on this question. I will not say that thereby the question cannot be posed in the discussion but it is absolutely necessary to consider the new milieu and to observe the necessary proportions." In overall very good to fine condition, with an occasional stain or short edge tear.