1420
Candelaria Mine Silver Ingot Mexico, San Dimas,Durango - 1885-1900 - 2012aug - Numismatic
Currency:USD
Category:Coins & Paper Money / Bullion
Start Price:2,500.00 USD
Estimated At:5,000.00 - 10,000.00 USD
SOLD
4,500.00USD+ (877.50) buyer's premium + applicable fees & taxes.
This item SOLD at 2012 Aug 18 @ 16:35UTC-7 : PDT/MST
Did you win this lot?
A full invoice should be emailed to the winner by the auctioneer within a day or two.
Invoicing and lot pick up will NOT be available at the live auction.
The history of the mine is an interesting one besides being a long and heart wrenching one. The mine was first located in 1783 by Juan Jose Zambrano, who was a storekeeper. The mine was near San Dimas, a small town “on the Guarisamé River” [Paulsen, 1981, 245]. Zambrano “built three tunnels to facilitate removal of the ore which was in veins one and one-half to three yards wide” [Paulsen, 1981, 245] During his lifetime, Zambrano took silver and gold out of the mine amounting to somewhere between 55 million to about 100 million dollars. At the end of his life in 1807, Zambrano had millions in banks in England and owned a huge amount of property in Durango City. Despite its obvious record of producing wealth, the mine fell into disarray after Zambrano’s death. Mexican politics also changed after the 1810 revolution. Because the mine was inactive, Mexican law concerning abandoned mines left the mine open for non related people to take it over. Brothers Miguel de and Jose Vicente Laveaga became the next owners of the mine but did not operate it at its full potential due to water problems.
Mark Brumagim (later to be known as Birmingham) was a forty-niner, got a report on the mine in 1863. At the time, American miners were seeking other mining ventures in other places in South America, such as in Peru and Bolivia, hoping to create another Comstock rush like what had recently happened in Nevada. The report on the Candelaria said it had great potential because its “ore samples [from the dry portions of the mine] contained gold, virgin silver, and black or sulfuret silver, and indicated a yield ranging from $200 to $1,120 per ton in gold alone” [Paulsen, 1981, 246]. Brumagim and some fellow investors from San Francisco decided to form a corporation and buy the mine. In July of 1863, Brumagim and friends incorporated the La Candelaria Mining Company of San Francisco after signing a “rehabilitation” contract with “the Laveaga brothers, who transferred twenty-three of twenty-four shares . . . together with a right to work 5,249 feet of the lode” [Paulsen, 1981, 246]. A rehabilitation contract meant the company “would do what was necessary to” bring the mine into full operation once again [Paulsen, 1981, 246]. Joseph G. Rice, a man who was married to Brumagim’s sister, was hired on to manage the mine. However, things did not go as planned as the company had problems getting the water out of the mine. It also had to put money into modernizing its stamp mill. The company soon ran out of money and had to reorganize. It reorganized in New York as the Durango Silver Mining Company. Brumagim still held the Laveaga shares. In 1865 he also purchased the remaining share from the Laveaga brothers for “$5,500." They moved to San Francisco. However, Rice made the deal for Brumagim, and the share remained in Rice’s name and was not immediately transferred to Brumagim. In 1866, after the 5th of May defeat of the French in Mexico, politics once again became unstable. The new company kept on spending money to rehabilitate the mine and it went into receivership in 1869. The company’s assets were sold at auction to the major shareholders of the Durango Mining Company of New York. Brumagim was one of the shareholders in the newly reformed company. Finally, “in 1880, sixteen years after Americans took control of the Candelaria, the drainage tunnel was finally completed” [Paulsen, 1981, 250]. The mine was not able to produce enough product to turn a profit. The investors were highly disappointed and “negotiated a renewable three-year lease with Columbus Waterhouse and Associates of San Francisco” [Paulsen, 1981, 250]. The Waterhouse people also retained an option to purchase the mine. They poured more money into the mine by adding “several miles of compressed-air pipe for drilling and ventilation” [Paulsen, 1981, 251]. Waterhouse also built a tramway, new crushing mills, and instituted “a more efficient amalgamation process” [Paulsen, 1981, 251]. By 1886, the mine had not produced any profits for its investors even though the mine was producing bullion and selling it. It was at this juncture that Brumagim was swindled out of his mine.
Otto Braunsdorf was the new mine manager after Rice. Waterhouse wanted to have the mine free and clear. Braunsdorf suggested that the Waterhouse’s managing director, Henry Weil, “denounce” the mine – that is declare it to be abandoned. However, denunciating a fully working mine was illegal under Mexican law. Nevertheless, Daniel M. Burns, “Waterhouse’s general manager in the San Dimas district, [decided to take] direct action. He filed a petition with Ramon Castro, the local political chief and federal mining agent, denouncing the Candelaria. Burns alleged that the mine and its annexes along 3,200 meters of the lode had been abandoned. The New York company directors, upon Waterhouse’s request, voted in May, without stockholder approval, to sell the Candelaria to him. Castro promptly accepted the reports of two mining experts, both employed by Burns, confirming the abandonment of the mine, and officially recognized Burns as its owner” [Paulsen, 1981, 252].
After finding out about the swindle, Brumagim spent the next years of his life trying to get his mine and the profits it finally realized returned to him. He started pursuing his goals in the U. S. court system and went through both the civil and criminal court systems in Mexico. He appealed to foreign diplomats as well as the U. S. ambassadors to Mexico without much luck. His sister even signed an affidavit in her capacity as the administratrix of her husband’s estate saying Brumagim was the true owner of the last Laveaga share. Nothing Brumagim did seemed to work. He had a good case. The Mexican Mining Law Code of 1884 in its Article 72 stated that mine managers could not denounce “other mines within 800 meters of his own, unless he did so for the owner. Because Burns had ‘fraudulently denounced’ the Candelaria for Waterhouse, he had violated his company’s lease” [Paulsen, 1981, 257]. Brugamim was still trying to pursue his day in court at the start of the 1910 Mexican Revolution. Brugamin died in 1914 not having realized his dreams of regaining ownership of the mine and getting recompensed for the millions he was cheated out of. However, “in 1917, the regime of President Venustiano Carranza nullified various decrees and decisions [made] between February of 1913 and September of 1914, including the decision to deny the Birmingham company possession of the property. In December of 1917 the Federal District Court in Mexico City finally declared the fraudulent denunciation null and void. The Candelaria Gold and Silver Mining Company was authorized to take possession of the mine, subject to Article 27 of the new Constitution of 1917 which nationalized subsoil deposits. While the company was pleased to have the denunciation voided, it refused to take possession subject to Article 27, preferring to pursue its claim for losses against the Mexican government. For reasons that are not entirely clear, the claim was never adjudicated. It was pending as late as 1937, at which time the United States claims commissioner was attempting to locate the company’s stockholders. As a result, the Candelaria remained in the hands of Burns and his Consolidated Candelaria Company. Perhaps Birmingham was fortunate in being spared the frustrations incurred by other American investors in Mexican properties who had to contend in the 1920s with the issue over retroactive application of the provisions of Article 27” [Paulsen, 1981, 265]. Ultimately, the Candelaria story reflects the conflicts and troubles Americans had with investing in South American properties. There was political unrest, changing rules, and difficulties in negotiating between the U.S. And other countries' laws [Paulsen, “The Legal Battle for the Candelaria Mine in Durango, Mexico, 1890-1917,” Journal of the Southwest, pp. 243-266, Vol. 23, No. 3 (Autumn, 1981)].
Top obverse 21 mm by 50 mm engraved and inscrolled with beautiful calligraphy. Inscription "DM" in fanciful capital lettering. The right side is 19 mm by 52 mm inscribed with calligraphy is "Candelaria Mine, San Dimas, Mexico." Burns is noted to have been the president of the mine at the turn of the twentieth century. However, this ingot has no inscription date. Other sides of the bar are uninscribed. The weight is 204.7 grams. A similar piece sold at Stacks in January of 2001. The mine produced a large amount of silver and gold. The main office for the mine was in San Francisco. Inscription of the president's initials on the ingot indicates his pride of ownership. At the turn of the century, ingots may have been provided to a handful of company investors to create excitement and show the successful growth of the mine.
-54423
Auction Location:
Atlantis Casino Resort ~ 3800 S. Virginia Street, Reno, Nevada, 89502, United States
Previewing Details:
Preview:
Holabird-Kagin Americana Office
3555 Airway Drive Suite#309
Reno, NV 89511
(Full preview, all items will be available for viewing)
Thursday - August 16, 12pm-6pm
Atlantis Casino & Resort
(Partial preview. Some of the oversized items will not be available for previewing at the Atlantis)
Friday Aug 17, 10am-6pm
Saturday Aug 18, 10am-6pm
Sales tax will apply, according to state law, for any items that ship to Nevada or California or are picked
up at our Reno, Nevada location, unless a current, valid re-sale certificate is provided at the time of
purchase.
Taxes:
Tax | Rate | Desc. |
NST |
7.725% |
Nevada Sales Tax: |
CST |
9% |
California Sales Tax: |
Buyer's Premiums:
From (Incl.) | To (Excl.) | Premium |
0.00 |
Infinite |
19.5% |
Additional Fees:
Shipping Details:
Shipping: Shipping will be estimated prior to invoicing, based on the size and weight of your purchase. Additional shipping fees may be invoiced seperately. The buyer is responsible for arranging and paying for shipment of large or special items. A $5 handling fee will be included in the shipping charge. The customer is responsible for all shipping charges. We do not ship any purchases until the auction invoice is paid in full. Purchases will be shipped via our approved, insured carriers, Federal Express or the US Postal Service. All items shipped Federal Express will be insured for the full value determined at auction by Holabird-Kagin Americana at no extra cost to the buyer. Federal Express shipments will be sent the Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday following receipt of payment. Pick up is available from our Reno office the next business day after the auction. NOTE: Some shipments (of unusual size, dimension, or weight) may require special handling for which individual costs will be calculated and applied to the shipping charge on the invoice.
Payment Details:
We accept Visa, Master Card, Money Order/Cashiers Check, Person Check, PayPal: HKAEbayRep@yahoo.com. A 3% discount is applied to the Buyer’s Premium on all sales. That discount will be reversed if payment is made with a credit card or through PayPal.
Accepted Payment Methods:
- VISA
- Master Card
- Money Order/Bank Draft
- Check/Cheque
- PayPal
Terms and Conditions
1. This is a Live Auction.
2. Live (Floor) Bidding: Please arrive a few minutes early to check in and receive your bidding paddle. We will open lots with more than one bid at the current high absentee bid or 50% of the low estimate at the auctioneer’s discretion. Please be sure to bid on the correct lots during the live auction. Our auction progress is at a rate of between 100 and 200 lots per hour. When the auctioneer says “sold”, he will identify the successful bidder by number and announce the winning bid amount. If you are not sure whether you won the lot or not, it is your responsibility to ask for clarification immediately. Tie bids are awarded to the first absentee bid placed if not advanced on the floor, or by a phone bidder, whoever is first. Auctioneer reserves the right to reopen the lot in the case of an immediate dispute at the actual time of the sale.
3. Telephone Bidding: Telephone bidding requests MUST be scheduled prior to this auction. If you do not schedule in advance, and choose instead to call on the day of the auction to request a line for bidding, you may find that we are unable to accommodate your request. Please limit your telephone bids to items of value greater than $500, or to a string of items with a similar total.
4. Agent Bidding: There are numerous professional agents available to assist you should you require this service. Please contact the office for a list or to arrange for representation on the floor during the live auction.
5. Live Auction Absentee Bidding: Absentee bids for the live auction will be accepted until Thursday, August 16, 2012 at 5pm PST. It is your responsibility to submit all lot numbers and bid amounts accurately. Absentee bids should be equal to at least 50% of the low estimate if an estimate is provided. Bids on “No Lots” or “Withdrawn” Lots are considered no-bids. Bids made in amounts that do not conform to the bid increment table in item 8 below will be automatically rounded up or down by the computer, or rounded to the nearest proper bid increment at the discretion of the auctioneer.
6. Internet Bidding: Absentee and Live internet bidding are both available through our live auction network. If you wish to bid LIVE via the internet, you MUST pre-register. A live video and sound feed will be accessible during the auction for those bidding via the internet. Online bidding remains open through the live auction and absentee bids may be placed anytime. Live bidding will open when the auction starts. Internet bidding is offered as a convenience for those who cannot attend the live sale. Please note that there may be delays or interruptions in internet connectivity that are beyond our control. Attending the live auction or arranging for an agent is the most reliable way to secure your bids.
WARNING: Auction participation through the live internet bidding site is not 100% foolproof. The technology for this process is still under review and development, and the operation of it, and the corresponding internet connectivity issues are far beyond our control. Some folks have attempted to use the live internet bidding process as their primary method of bidding, and have been quite successful. Others have failed completely. Depending upon your computer, server, host and other factors, internet signals may be delayed, such that bids may not be received in time. We cannot be held responsible for these delays, or for the lack of placed bids in a timely manner, or any other factors leading to unaccepted bids that are far beyond our control. Bidders should always have a backup plan for lots they highly desire. Live participation is best, followed by phone participation. We will not reopen lots for missed bids.
7. Reserves: Most of the lots in this auction are unreserved. Gold is generally reserved at or near spot, though it could be slightly below spot.
8. Bidding Increments: All bids must be submitted in U.S. dollars and in whole dollar amounts only in the appropriate increments as outlined below. IF you choose to submit bids in an increment not listed below, your bid will be rounded to the nearest increment and you will be expected to pay the amount to which the bid was rounded should your bid be the winning bid. If you have any questions about an appropriate bid amount, please call us.
From: To: Increment:
$0 $29 $1
$30 $95 $5
$100 $190 $10
$200 $475 $25
$500 $1,450 $50
$1,500 $3,400 $100
$3,500 $9,750 $250
$10,000 $max $500
9. Bid Reduction: All winning absentee bids will be reduced, if necessary, to the next bidding increment up from the last competing bid, as long as the minimum bid requirement has been met. For example, if you submit an absentee bid of $1000 and the next highest competing bid is $250, then you will win the lot for $275.
10. Bid Information: Collectors often ask in advance the price level of a particular lot. We will give out the current high absentee bid until we close the day before the live auction. You may also view absentee bids online at www.holabirdamericana.com.
11. Bid Cancellation: If you wish to cancel or change a bid after you have submitted your bids to us due to an error, you MUST PHONE us to advise us of this. Bid cancellations through mail, email, or fax are not advisable. Errors are easy to make and we are happy to assist all callers.
12. All stock certificates, checks, warrants, and other financial documents sold herein are sold as antiquities, and have no financial, securities, or public trading value whatsoever.
13. We reserve the right to reject any bid we feel is not made in good faith.
14. The placing of a bid shall constitute the bidder’s acceptance of these terms of sale.
15. Buyer’s Premium: There will be a 19.5% Buyer’s Premium added to each lot. US coins, nuggets, and bullion are calculated at a 15% buyer’s premium. These premiums includes a 3% discount for transactions paid with cash, checks, money orders or wire transfers. All other forms of payment are not subject to the 3% discount and the Buyer’s Premium will be calculated at 22.5% (18% on US coins, gold, & currency.)
16. Sales Tax: Sales tax will apply, according to state law, for any items that ship to Nevada (7.725%) or California (9.0%) unless a current, valid resale certificate is faxed to us at 775-852-8866 before bids are placed.
17. Invoicing: Shipping charges will be added to all invoices. Invoices are mailed or emailed within two business days after the close of all portions of the sale. Within 15 days of receipt of invoice, payment is due in full to Holabird-Kagin Americana, 3555 Airway Dr., #308, Reno, NV 89511. We accept cash, personal checks, money orders, wire transfers, etc. All returned checks are subject to a $25 fee. Cash received in amounts greater than $10,000 is subject to the filing of IRS form 8300, as required by law. Sales tax will be added to all sales picked-up after the auction or shipped to California or Nevada addresses, according to state law, unless a resale certificate is provided.
18. Payment: We accept Visa, Master Card, Money Order/Cashier’s Check, Personal Check, PayPal: HKAEbayRep@yahoo.com. A 3% discount is applied to the Buyer’s Premium on all sales. That discount will be reversed if payment is made with a credit card or through PayPal.
19. Shipping: Shipping will be estimated prior to invoicing, based on the size and weight of your purchase. Additional shipping fees may be invoiced seperately. The buyer is responsible for arranging and paying for shipment of large or special items. A $5 handling fee will be included in the shipping charge. The customer is responsible for all shipping charges. We do not ship any purchases until the auction invoice is paid in full. Purchases will be shipped via our approved, insured carriers, Federal Express or the US Postal Service. All items shipped Federal Express will be insured for the full value determined at auction by Holabird-Kagin Americana at no extra cost to the buyer. Federal Express shipments will be sent the Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday following receipt of payment. Pick up is available from our Reno office the next business day after the auction. NOTE: Some shipments (of unusual size, dimension, or weight) may require special handling for which individual costs will be calculated and applied to the shipping charge on the invoice.
20. Return Policy: All items are guaranteed to be authentic. If authenticity is challenged, please call our office for assistance. You may return any piece that was significantly inaccurately described by calling our office within one week of receipt of item(s) and notifying us of the error and reason for return. We do not refund postage or insurance. We have attempted to describe the items and their condition accurately. If no condition is given, assume average. Please call us if you require a more specific condition report. Any items that are returned must be returned in the exact, unaltered condition. NGC certified tokens that are returned must be original, unaltered NGC holders. Any tokens removed from the original NGC/NCS certification holders or items returned in an altered condition are deemed not returnable under any circumstances. When we receive your bids we will assume you have read the description in the catalog, viewed the image of the item, have contacted us regarding any questions you may have on any lot and/or have previewed the lot in person. Therefore, returns are only accepted if prior approval is given by Holabird-Kagin Americana.
21. This sale is being held under the laws of the states of Nevada and California.
22. Neither Kagin’s, Inc. nor its subsidiary auction company Holabird-Kagin Americana shall not be held responsible for any problem due to the bidders failure to follow the rules, terms and conditions of this sale, or any failure to bid due to the loss of the online auction process provided by any of the online auction networks; or missed bids, changed bids or cancelled due the bidders failure to follow the proper bidding procedure outlined herein.